Cubs Blow 8-Run Lead in 1929 World Series!



Panoramic Photo Above:

Forbes Field, Pittsburgh

Baseball History Comes Alive Now Ranked As a Top Five Website by Feedspot Among All Baseball History Websites and Blogs!

(Check out Feedspot's list of the Top 35 Baseball History websites and blogs)




Guest Submissions from Our Readers Always Welcome! Click for details

Visit the Baseball History Comes Alive Home Page
Subscribe to Baseball History Comes Alive
Free Bonus for Subscribing:
Gary’s Handy Dandy World Series Reference Guide
Get new posts by email
1929 World Series Photo Gallery

Cubs Blow 8-Run Lead in 1929 World Series!

With the 2025 World Series just around the corner, I always like to recall some of the more memorable Fall Classics from the past. Today, we’ll take a look at the 1929 World Series between the Cubs and the Philadelphia Athletics. However, if you’re a Cub fan, the memories are not good. The Series became famous for the Cubs blowing a big lead in the seventh inning of Game Four at Shibe Park.

(In the featured photos, we see Cub star Rogers Hornsby in 1929)

In that fateful frame, the Cubs somehow managed to let a seemingly insurmountable eight-run lead slip away thanks to Hack Wilson losing two balls in the sun. This allowed the A’s to score ten runs [!] in the home half of the inning. In doing so, the A’s snatched a 10–8 victory from the jaws of near-certain defeat.

 Hack Wilson

Connie Mack’s great 1929 A’s posted a 104-46 (.693) record in the regular season, finishing 18 games ahead of the Yankees; while Joe McCarthy won his first of nine pennants, leading the Cubs to a 98-54 (.645) season, 10.5 games ahead of the Pirates. No less that nine future Hall of Fame players appeared in the Series: A’s Mickey Cochrane, Jimmie Foxx, Lefty Grove, Eddie Collins, and Al Simmons; while the Cub stars included Kiki Cuyler, Gabby Hartnett, Rogers Hornsby, and Hack Wilson. Also in the Series were the two Hall of Fame managers, Mack and McCarthy, and umpire Bill Klem. 

The first game at Wrigley Field featured a surprise starter for the A’s: sore-armed righty Howard Ehmke, who had been only an occasional starter during the regular season. He was chosen by Mack instead of his southpaw aces, Lefty Grove and Rube Wallberg, as a counter to the Cubs’ starting lineup that featured seven right-handed batters. Throughout the Series, Mack started only his right-handers, while keeping his lefties in the bullpen. The gamble paid off, as Ehmke cruised to a 3-1 complete game victory . His 13 strikeouts broke the World Series record set by Ed Walsh in 1906.

Howard Ehmke

After the Athletics took the first two contests in Chicago, the Cubs rallied to win Game Three, at Shibe Park,  behind Guy Bush’s strong pitching. They now had veteran staff ace Charlie Root scheduled to take the mount for Game Four, and 22-game-winner Pat Malone ready for Game Five. The final two games would be back at Wrigley Field, where the Cubs had been nearly unbeatable that summer, at 52-25. They were down 2-0, but things were looking up for the Cubs as Game Four loomed.

The Fateful Seventh Inning…

The North Siders gave Root a nice eight-run cushion as the fourth game entered the seventh inning. Nine more outs was all Root needed and the Series would be tied at two games apiece. Al Simmons, Philadelphia’s slugging left fielder, led off. On Root’s third offering, “Bucketfoot Al” hit a home run to left that cleared the roof. The shutout was lost, and the home town Philadelphia fans finally had something to cheer about.

Next batter Jimmie Foxx singled, and then Bing Miller hit a fly ball to center. A staggering Hack Wilson lost it in the sun, and it fell in for a single with Foxx taking second. Singles by Jimmy Dykes and Joe Boley scored Foxx and Miller to make it 8-3.

A bad start, but the worst was yet to come…

With runners on first and third and nobody out, George Burns pinch hit for pitcher Eddie Rommel. He was quickly retired on a pop fly to shortstop Woody English, with the runners holding. Max Bishop, who had hit only .232 during the regular season, then singled to left, scoring Dykes, and sending Boley to third. Suddenly the Cubs lead had been cut in half. McCarthy headed to the mound, took the ball from a frustrated Root, and waved in veteran lefty Art Nehf from the bullpen to face the left-handed-hitting Mule Haas.

1929: The Philadelphia Athletics celebrate in 1929 World Series (Getty Images)

What happened next is best described by Scott Ferkovich in his SABR Bioproject article on the 1929 World Series:

“In center field, Wilson adjusted his cap and dark sunglasses, the better to peer in against the blinding beams of the sun. One out, runners on first and third, 8-4 in favor of Chicago. Mule Haas, who had hit 16 home runs in 1929, sent Nehf’s first fastball on a line toward center field. Wilson drifted back. Despite his sunglasses, he again lost the ball in the glare. It soared over his head and rolled to the fence. The desperate outfielder ran the ball down, Boley and Bishop scoring. Haas, defying his nickname, sprinted like lightning around the bases. Wilson heaved a late throw in, and Haas slid into the home dish in a cloud of dust. The Cubs had blinked, and the score was suddenly Chicago 8, Philadelphia 7, with only one out.”

“The 36-year-old Nehf, winner of 184 games over 15 seasons, walked Mickey Cochrane. McCarthy, for the second time in the inning, marched out to the mound, and Nehf, for the final time in his big-league career, marched off of it.”

“Enter pitcher ‘Sheriff’ Blake. Al Simmons, back in the saddle for the second time that inning, singled to left. Foxx did the same, scoring Cochrane to tie it. McCarthy yanked the ball from Blake and tried his luck with Pat Malone, who plunked Bing Miller with his first pitch. Jimmy Dykes doubled, driving in two more to put the Athletics up by a deuce.”

“The Shibe Park crowd was delirious with delight. Strikeouts by Boley and Burns brought the frame to an end, but the book had already been written. Athletics manager Connie Mack brought in Lefty Grove, winner of 20 in 1929, to start the eighth. He fanned four of the six batters he faced. At 3:42 pm, Rogers Hornsby flied to left for the final out of the game. Wilson was left on one knee in the on-deck circle. What had looked like a 2-2 Series tie had suddenly become a three-games-to-one Athletics lead. Chicago never recovered. They lost the Series the following day in equally heartbreaking fashion, when Philadelphia scored three runs in the bottom of the ninth to wipe out a 2-0 Cubs lead.”

For Cub fans like me, it’s always painful to recall this game which featured arguably the worst inning in Cub history!

Gary Livacari

Photo Credits: All from Google search

Information: Excerpts edited from the 1929 World SeriesWikipedia page; and from Scott Ferkovich in his SABR Bioproject article on the 1929 World Series

Subscribe to Baseball History Comes Alive. FREE BONUS for subscribing: Gary’s Handy Dandy World Series Reference Guide.  https://wp.me/P7a04E-2he

Get new posts by email

Visit the Baseball History Comes Alive Home Page

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

close

Click "Follow" For Automatic Updates and You'll Receive Within 24-Hours My Free Bonus Report:

Gary's Handy Dandy World Series Reference Guide!

error

Click "Follow" For Automatic Updates and Free Bonus Report: Gary's Handy Dandy World Series Reference Guide!