Subscribe to Baseball History Comes Alive

Free Bonus for Subscribing:

Gary’s Handy Dandy World Series Reference Guide

Get new posts by email

Most of us are familiar with the Blue Laws that prohibited sales of alcohol in the early 20th century. But how many know that the Blue Laws also forbade playing baseball on Sundays? Ron Christensen provides us a nice review of how these laws affected the early game. I found it interesting, and I think you will too. -GL

BLUE LAW BLUES!

BRIDGEPORT BASEBALL TEAM ARRESTED .  .  .  AGAIN!

Recidivism is a legal term referring to an individual’s relapse into criminal behavior, essentially the tendency of someone convicted of a crime to offend again in the future.  Well, in the summer of 1913, the Bridgeport Mechanics, a minor league baseball team, did exactly that.  Players, manager, an umpire, and even a ticket seller were all taken into custody pursuant to warrants issued for their arrests.  Following a trial in the Court, all were found guilty by a judge who imposed a $15.00 fine on each defendant.

So, did the Mechanics, et al, learn their collective lesson?  Perish the thought!  Three days after the fines were levied, they went out and did it again.  And they did it again after that.  So what did these hardened criminals of baseball do to warrant so much fuss with the law?  They violated Connecticut’s longstanding “Blue Laws” by playing baseball on Sunday.

Blue Laws have been a part of our governance since Colonial times.  Often referred to as ‘Sunday Laws,’  Blue Laws were originally adopted to serve a religious purpose, specifically to promote the observance of the Christian day of worship – Sunday.  In doing so, Blue Laws restricted or banned many recreational and business activities from taking place on Sunday.  Intended to enforce a Puritan view of morality, Blue Laws were arguably harsher in Colonial Connecticut, where Puritanism was sometimes too Puritanical even for Puritans.

Fast forward to 1913 and the continued grip of Blue Laws on Sunday baseball long after the Colonial Era had ended.  With the dawn of the new century, the passing of the Gilded Age, and the influx of immigration that brought many non-Protestants to our shores, people looked at Sundays in a whole new light.  Many continued to reserve the morning hours for church and worship, but come afternoon, it was time to play baseball.  To quote Bob Dylan, “the times they are a changin’.”

But alas, throughout Connecticut, there still existed clusters of pious Yankee traditionalists who maintained a steadfast, albeit blind, adherence to the sanctity of Blue Laws.  None of these was more formidable than Bridgeport’s Pastors Association.  Sunday baseball was simply too much for them to bear, so they assumed the mantle of torchbearer in leading the charge of enforcing the Blue Laws to prohibit the exhibition of commercial sporting events on Sunday.

The Pastors presented their complaints to the Bridgeport States Attorney, who seemed more of a baseball fan than expected and less enthusiastic in pursuing arrest warrants than anticipated.  Undeterred, the Pastors hired a private detective to attend the Mechanics Sunday games.  After witnessing (and enjoying) a few of these, the detective submitted a written report confirming the playing of baseball on Sunday, and included within the names of those who participated.  The Pastors, with report in hand, again approached the States Attorney, and this time warrants were issued, and arrests were made.

The prosecuting zeal (sarcasm emoji here) of the States Attorney was clearly evident in his remark made during trial that he thought it was better “to have the public witnessing a baseball game than participating in card playing where profanity and immorality prevail.”  When, after their first conviction, the Mechanics dared to play Sunday ball again, and then did so again after a second conviction, it became necessary for the irate Pastors to lodge their complaints with the Bridgeport Police Chief, as the States Attorney was no longer viewed as an ally.

The Mechanics, a minor league team loosely affiliated with the New York Yankees because their manager, Gene McCann, was a former Yankees scout (the name ‘Mechanics’ was derived from the name ‘McCann’), were one of many such baseball teams challenging the logic and utility of the Sunday Blue Laws and their application to commercial sporting ventures.  But the winds of change were slow to arrive.  It wasn’t until 1921 that the Connecticut General Assembly approved a bill allowing Sunday recreation, one that was promptly vetoed by the Connecticut Governor, calling it “one of the greatest menaces to the stability of the nation!”  Finally, in 1925, under the leadership of a new and more enlightened Governor, Connecticut finally enacted a law permitting commercial sporting events, including baseball, to be played on Sunday.

The Bridgeport Mechanics, a team of dedicated minor leaguers who never won a championship, nonetheless championed the cause of Blue Law reform. They placed themselves in the crosshairs of the legal system in an effort to promote and expand America’s baseball pastime in early 20th-century Connecticut.

Ron Christensen

REFERENCES:

1. Today In Connecticut History, by Walt Woodward
2. Wikipedia: Connecticut Blue Laws
3. Wikipedia: Blue Laws

Photo Credits: All found on Google search

Subscribe to Baseball History Comes Alive. FREE BONUS for subscribing: Gary’s Handy Dandy World Series Reference Guide.  https://wp.me/P7a04E-2he

Visit the Baseball History Comes Alive Home Page